Saturday, February 25, 2012

'Education' abroad....yeah...I don't know-part 2

Its been a while since my last post. Well I've been busy, but lets take it from where I left off  in my previous post. Continuing on with the career aspect of studying abroad, lets shift focus on what happens after you finish your masters degree. There are three options here for you to consider-
  1. Get a job, and work for which you will need a work visa(H1B in the US). Changing your status from student to skilled worker isn't as easy as it sounds, more on it in a moment
  2. Continue on with your studies and get a higher degree (a Phd). This is the move for people who want a career in research.
  3. This is the last AND the least option. Returning to India. This is like the most feared option for most people studying abroad. The prospect of returning to your home country with a possibility of a huge student debt sounds like the big fat American dream went bust!
So, lets dig deeper into each of these options one by one.  Lets start with getting a job. As aforementioned in the previous post, most of my writing will be US specific. But it ought to hold good for most other western countries and their economies.To start with, lets get a little perspective on this whole H1-B visa.  Getting a job is what most Indians really go to the US to study for. That mouth watering dollar salary with an extra topping of the dollar-rupee conversion rate is what drives a lot of people to take insanely high student loans and invest so much time and money into this whole exercise. In fact, probably 20 years ago, in the 90s, when this whole mass exodus of India's tech talent to the US reached its crescendo, most people went to the US directly on a H1-B work visa(a lot of which were on offer then when compared to now) which gave birth to a whole lot of rags to riches stories of Indians making it big in the US. Then, there was no sham of a masters degree. It was a no nonsense, get to the point direct route. You wanted a better life in America, you directly applied for a work visa. Then, 9/11 happened. That singular event caused such an overhaul of America's immigration and security systems that after 9/11  you'd be joking if you directly applied for a job in America from India and hoped to get a H1-B. Post 2001, Indians started taking another route to the US. Go as a student and then after studying change your status from student to work. It was a genius plan and it did work for some time. But, the 2008 recession screwed its effectiveness and the present crop of Indian students going to study abroad, hoping to replicate the success of their predecessors, are largely unaware of this fact(Hell, the present crop is largely unaware of why they're going in the first place!). 

Anyway, enough of perspective. Now to get to the point (I know its about time!), getting a job now in the US, in this economy  is not as easy as it used to be. To add to your woes, getting a H1-B also isn't. You see, unlike the student visa, the applicants themselves cant apply for a work visa directly. The employer needs to apply on their behalf. The cruel twist of fate here is, there are not a lot of employers around who'd want to do that. Why? Well why would someone go through all the trouble of dealing with the US immigration department(like that's easy!) to employ a foreign worker unless he/she is really worth it? They re better off hiring local talent. So except the big MNC's not a lot of small startups hire foreign talent, and trust me, getting a job in big MNC as a fresh college grad ain't no mean job!  So to sum it up, there aren't that many jobs, with that you have an additional constraint of narrowing down your search to employers who are ready to sponsor an H1B and to add to that you have a limited time to do that. So unless you can deal with all that, go figure! 

Now apart from the immigration issues another thing I'd like to add is that, campus placements for international students in US universities is like a joke. Most companies who hire in job fairs, hire only US citizens or green card holders. International students need to entirely depend on references from their professors or rely on professional networking to get a job, or even an internship. So please stop looking at US news rankings to decide on a university, unless you make it to an Ivy league school, because, frankly speaking you're employers don't give a rats ass about which university your from! Intuitively,that makes sense because if doing you're masters is a means to achieve an end and not for academic salvation, the quality of your university really shouldn't matter. 

 Many people could argue that I might be over rating stuff because the US government gives everyone an Optional Practical Training (OPT) period to get a job. But that ironically can lead to your downfall. The OPT program, after you finish your studies, offers you a 3 month window to search for a job. If you cant, then you simply pack up and leave. Its insanely hard to expect to bag a job in that much time unless you have an equally insane amount of contacts in the industry. Most people combat this by getting an internship during summers(which again depends on your contacts and references) and try and bag a job in the same company or delay their graduation to borrow more time. Basically, by the final semester of your course, if you came to the US to look for a job and you want to pay off your huge student loans, you my friend, have got a hell of a lot on your plate and you need to be either an extremely bright student or need to be exceptionally street smart or you might find yourself in a big mess. Bigger than what you bargained for. 

Some students in their desperation also end up at job consultancies which only really offer a lot of  IT contract based jobs. That means the whole point of you going abroad to pursue a career in your area of interest, assuming its not IT, is defeated. Taking for example again the semiconductors industry. Most of the entry level jobs in this industry are here in India simply because big  MNC's cant afford to keep those jobs in the US. So if you went to the US to get a masters in VLSI and wanted to a career as a VLSI engineer, you wont find a lot of openings for your level of experience unless of course you re really worth hiring or you have lots of references within the industry. So be industry specific. See if your industry is really good in the US with a lot of openings or is it better off in India. Do not listen to some uncle of yours or some friend or some educational consultant or some random person who says that there are more 'opportunities' abroad or a better 'future' or a masters degree has 'value'. Its generic statements like these that absolutely piss me off! 

The biggest anti-climax to all of this would be if the country to which you went cancelled the post study work authorization for international students. This is exactly what happened in the UK. So at the end you face the same basic drawback- you re in a foreign country and you are at the mercy of a foreign government. This is one fact you can never afford to overlook. 


Now after that rather lengthy discussion about the first option, lets take a look at your second option. A Phd. Lets face it. Generally, people who dont get a job after their masters, to legally stay in status as a student go for this option. Real Phd aspirants who go on a research scholarship and have some kind of a career waiting for them in research are getting lesser and lesser. I have a cousin who studies at Rice university, which is an ivy league school, who went to the US on a scholarship, got a Phd and is doing some really useful research in signal processing. People like him are getting rarer. Most work that gets passed off as research these days for a Phd degree isn't really of high quality or has some meaningful ramification. So if you want a career in research that means something  you better make sure that you are at a university of some repute and you re research isn't some redundant, irrelevant stuff which is just an excuse for a lot of people just to stay in status. 

Now to touch upon the final subject of the poor souls that return to India empty handed. You would be surprised to know that the industry here just sees you as another fresher and offers the same salary as any other fresher. No special treatment just because you got your degree abroad. Blame that on that large number of students who go abroad to study,which has reduced the sheen on a foreign degree or on the fact that most recruiters simply don't  give a shit about your degree and focus on industry specific skills. Either way, if you depended on your degree to pay for itself and your student loan then kiss those chances good bye. With the salary that you get in India I don't think you can pay off that huge a loan in the amount of time the bank gives you and banks are known to have a thin patience in such matters. If your parents funded your education then well, you lost a huge chunk of their savings, unless of course you come from some uber rich family and the amount of money you spent was insignificant to them. Basically you don't get a return of investment. I touched upon this because before taking a huge loan or investing such a huge amount you need to take into consideration this possibility too.


Saturday, January 28, 2012

'Education' abroad....yeah..I dont know-Part1

Disclaimer: Because people in this part of the world generally go apeshit when an opinion is antithetical in essence to the overwhelming majority of opinions, I would like to say that I am not against higher education abroad per se . My views and writings  are an effort to acquaint people with reality of  things and set right the balance which has been unfairly tilted towards the richness and bounty associated with foreign education. Also, I need a muse when I'm bored so deal with it!

Well, its my first post. I couldnt help but  write about the one thing that has occupied my mind since the months Ive graduated from college. Yes, higher education, outside of India. What Im going to write here  will mainly be pertaining to the US and thats just because of my personal experience and the experiences of people close to me who are currently pursuing their masters in the US.

So lets get started. Whats this whole deal about a masters(or any other degree really) in the US? Is it worth it or not? Well, I feel the answer is depends. Depends on what you want in your life, in your career, your financial background growing up and also not in the least, your attachment to your loved ones. Lets make sense of this from each perspective.

First the career aspect. Before you people out there start running to educational 'consultants'(yeah right) and making your list of safe, moderate and dream universities and feel all nice and dandy about your choices, stop and think whether you really need a master's degree in your line of work. It might be hard to believe but sometimes you just dont need one! Most people whom I have come across applying to universities spend more time frolicking about how much fun they re going to have doing stuff in the US (they kinda forget that you need money for that!) than evaluating objectively and logically what this degree will do to their career. I get it. We re from India and your first trip abroad that too to a first world country might make you feel all excited but it ends there. Once you land there and reality hits you, the excitement evaporates pretty instantaneously.  Now let me make my point . Lets take for example what has recently been a pretty popular domain for people with an electronics/electrical engineering major to do their masters in-A masters in the VLSI/semiconductors domain. Now if you want to get a masters and go on to do a Phd and have a career in academia, well, theres no other place like the US. But, if what you want is a career in the semiconductor industry, then a masters degree is not really the way to go. You see, your potential employer in the industry looks at what skills you bring with you to the company rather than what degrees you bring. More specifically , they look at what experience you have work with industry standard VLSI tools, which you can get right here in India at a fraction of the price you pay for a masters. Seriously, many people who go for a masters in VLSI have no inkling whether their university provides them access to such tools or how many of the credits they complete towards getting their degree will be composed of VLSI courses. I know people who went to the US to get a masters in VLSI and now theyre getting a masters which specializes in well, nothing because their university just doesnt have enough courses in VLSI to get a degree! So before going abroad you need to decide whether you have a better shot at having a career abroad rather than going just for the sake of it.
More to come in the next post.